Trimming the Training Budget During a Recession? You Will Pay Later

I just ran across a well-written article that sums up the reason why you should never cut your training budget in a recession.  I know it’s tempting.  Training and Organizational Development have always been challenged to show ROI.  After all, the activities involved in training do not tie directly to the bottom line, and soft skills training is tough to measure.


However, the statistics on this topic are clear.  Michael Haberman, the author of the article, makes the point very clearly:

People feel more valued when they realize the company is willing to invest money in their skill sets, despite tough times. Yes, I understand that people with a job are probably going to stay put whether or not they are trained. However, when the recovery starts (and it will, with or without the help of the government) employees who felt valued will be most likely to stay put when opportunities become available. Turnover is expensive and anything you can do to retain good workers will be beneficial. Training will help accomplish that.

Here’s the real question?  Does the kind of training matter?  Not really.  The honest truth is that your employees need to feel valued.  Investing in your employees through training will pay you back through increased skills, engagement, and longer tenure.  

The cost of disengagement and turnover are devastating.  Some researchers estimate that disengagement costs US companies $300 Billion annually, and turnover can reach as much as 200% of the position’s salary.  

Ladies and gentlemen, if we’re not talking dollars, then we’re not making sense.  Training isn’t some fluffy HR outing with trust falls.  True training and development supports continuing education, skill development, and focuses on necessary competencies to perform a job.

So, instead of cutting training outright, find ways to extend the training in new ways.  HR Magazine had some great suggestions for training on a shoe-string budget in January 2009.

A few key ideas were to:
  • Reduce the travel budget for the training– can the training be done online via webinar?  We live in a virtual world- grab a webcam for $50 and save on your airfare.  
  • Keep the business going– instead of taking everyone out of business for a half-day, try to separate the training into two shifts, so productivity stays steady and everyone receives the training.
  • Brown bag it– If you’re running an all-day training, don’t feel you have to cater in lunch.  Additionally, consider holding “lunch and learn” meetings.  Hold open one-hour trainings/discussions on a topic and people can voluntarily join and bring a brown bag for lunch.
  • Put your training online, so development happens On-Demand.
  • Create a company wiki where employees can share their knowledge
There are many ways to use technology to maintain a strong training curriculum that won’t break the budget.  Regardless, executives should be careful not to overlook the value they hold in their hands.  At the end of the day 90% of your organization’s capital walk out the door (your human capital).  Invest in your capital, and you will see a significant return on your investment.

In a Recession, What Cut Backs Do You Refuse to Make?

Several of my friends are out of work, and we’ve been discussing what they have had to cut out of their budget to make ends meet.  Laurie Ruettimann even posted the question on her blog and had a great discussion in the comments:  http://punkrockhr.com/2009/05/04/punk-rock-hr-recession-watch-toilet-paper/comment-page-1/#comment-8490


I’m fascinated by the things people will or won’t give up.  I also often find that the things we give up often relate to the Thinking/Feeling preferences.  

So, I pose the question to you….what are you NOT willing to give up and what is your type?  We’ll have a little mini-case study of the readers.

Keep an open mind when thinking of the luxury items you refuse to cut out of the budget:
  • Starbucks?
  • Manicures?
  • Coloring your hair?
  • Two-ply toilet paper?
  • Name brand products (i.e. are you buying generic now?)
  • Premium Orange juice (nice one, @tonytsheng)
  • charitable donations? (a Twitter friend who is ENFJ says she won’t give up compassion!)
  • magazines?
  • movie channels?
  • date nights out?
  • cable?
  • high speed Internet? (as a Twitter INTJ friend reported: I refuse to give up my internet access or independent thinking!~~  I love that!)
  • Texting?
  • gifts for birthdays?
  • greeting cards?
  • tech gadgets?
  • as seen on tv stuff? (I wish I could, but I just can’t give this junk up!)
  • saving for your kids’ college fund?
  • Lottery tickets?
I’m finding that my Feeling preference friends refuse to give up things that affect others life gifts, donations, and gift cards.  

I’m a Thinking preference, so I’m the opposite.  I think through what I can cut out without being impacted.  For instance, I can give up magazines and check them out the next time I get my hair done (or at the library) instead.  I could cut out movie channels because I can wait until the movies come out on DVD at the RedBox.

So, how about you?  What won’t you give up, and how does it relate to your type (or does it)?

Thinking vs. Feeling- A little humor for your Monday…

s you all know by now, I’m a big fan of Punk Rock HRand the author Laurie Ruettimann.  She always posts something funny on Mondays, and today I couldn’t help but share.

This “Hurt Feelings Report” has to resonate with those who have a Thinking preference (and I’m positive some people with a clear Feeling preference will be appalled….it’s humor, folks!).  I’m pretty sure I could use this form on a daily basis.  The “did you require a tissue for your tears” question was the best!  To view the report in full size, click here.
Okay, Thinkers, we’ve gotten our laughs for the day…now back to working on being understanding again!

 

Carl Jung Quote of the Day

It all depends on how we look at things, and not how they are in themselves.